Skip to main content Skip to main navigation Skip to search

Queensland and NSW floods 2022

Visit recovery.gov.au to see what help is available.

Close
Home

Top navigation main

  • News & media
  • Jobs
  • Ministers
  • Contact us
Main menu

AWE Main

  • Climate change
    Climate change Driving climate action, science and innovation so we are ready for the future.
    • Climate science and adaptation
    • Australia's climate change strategies
    • Emissions reduction
    • Emissions reporting
    • International commitments
    • Climate Active
    • Climate change publications and data
    • Australia’s National Greenhouse Accounts (Emissions Data)
    Stronger action on climate change

    Stronger action on climate change

    See how the Australian Government is committed to taking more ambitious action on climate change.

    Find out more

  • Energy
    Energy Building a secure and sustainable energy system for all Australians.
    • Energy policy in Australia
    • Energy ministers
    • Renewable energy
    • Energy publications
    • energy.gov.au
    • Energy Rating
    • Commercial Building Disclosure Program
    • Nationwide House Energy Rating Scheme (NatHERS)
    • Your Home
    Decorative image

    Australian Energy Employment Report survey

    Share insights to help the energy workforce plan for the future

    Find out more

  • Environment
    Environment Improving stewardship and sustainable management of Australia’s environment.
    • Bushfire recovery
    • Climate change and the environment
    • Biodiversity
    • EPBC Act
    • Environmental information and data
    • International activities
    • Invasive species
    • Land
    • Marine
    • Partnerships
    • Protection
    • Report a breach of environment law
    • Threatened species & ecological communities
    • Waste and recycling
    • Wildlife trade
    Decorative image

    Read our Nature Positive Plan

    Our plan sets out the Australian Government’s commitment to environmental law reform

    Find out more

  • Water
    Water Improving the sustainable management of Australia’s water supply for industry, the environment and communities.
    • Coal, Coal seam gas (CSG) and water
    • Commonwealth Environmental Water Office
    • Water policy and resources
    • Wetlands
    Water matters

    Water Matters

    Keep up with the latest news on the department's work in managing Australia's water resources.

    Read the latest edition here

  • Parks and heritage
    Parks and heritage Managing Australia’s iconic national parks, historic places and living landscapes.
    • Australian Marine Parks
    • Australian National Botanic Gardens
    • Booderee National Park
    • Kakadu National Park
    • Christmas Island National Park
    • National parks
    • Norfolk Island National Park
    • Heritage
    • Pulu Keeling National Park
    • The Great Barrier Reef
    • Uluṟu-Kata Tjuṯa National Park
    The reef

    Great Barrier Reef

    Australia is protecting and conserving this World Heritage Area.

    Find out more

  • Science and research
    Science and research Undertaking research and collecting data to support informed decisions and policies.
    • Climate change
    • Australia's biological resources
    • National Environmental Science Program (NESP)
    • Our science strategy
    • Australian Biological Resource Study (ABRS)
    • State of the Environment (SoE) reporting
    • Bird and bat banding
    • Supervising Scientist
    Our climate is changing

    Our climate is changing

    Find out more about how climate science helps Australians with the impacts of climate change.

    Find out more

  • About us
    About us We lead Australia’s response to climate change and sustainable energy use, and protect our environment, heritage and water.
    • Accountability and reporting
    • Assistance, grants and tenders
    • Fees and charges
    • News and media
    • Our commitment to you
    • People and jobs
    • Publications
    • What we do
    • Who we are
    Decorative image

    Juukan Gorge response

    Read the Australian Government's response to the destruction at Juukan Gorge and the recommendations

    Read the response

  • Online services
    Online services We do business with you using online platforms. This makes it easier for you to meet your legal requirements.
Department of Climate Change, Energy, Enviroment and Water

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Parks and heritage
  3. National Parks
  4. Parks Australia
  5. Publications | Parks Australia
  6. Senior Advisory Group on Joint Management Arrangements for Commonwealth National Parks Advice to the Minister for the Environment

Sidebar first - EN - National parks

  • Parks Australia
    • The Director of National Parks
    • Media releases
    • Media centre
    • Freedom of Information
    • Privacy Policy
    • Public Interest Disclosure
    • Climate Change
    • Permits, licences and leases
    • Procurement Feedback Guidelines
    • Publications

Senior Advisory Group on Joint Management Arrangements for Commonwealth National Parks Advice to the Minister for the Environment

2021
Senior Advisory Group
Download
Senior Advisory Group on Joint Management Arrangements for Commonwealth National Parks Advice to the Minister for the Environment (PDF 2MB)
Front cover

Foreword

The Minister rightly recognised that the governance, structure and culture of the jointly managed parks required in-depth review. She established the Senior Advisory Group to recommend a pathway to a better future for the parks, ensuring that the Traditional Owners of the land were front and centre of future discussions on joint management arrangements.

The best and brightest future for the parks is one where first, local traditional culture flourishes and heritage is protected and second, the Director of National Parks (DNP) is an effective manager. That requires a strong relationship between Traditional Owners and Parks Australia. There isn’t one. Parks Australia has lost the trust and confidence of the Traditional Owners.

Relationship change is crucial and must be an immediate focus. Traditional Owners have felt disempowered. Repairing decades of deteriorating relationships is not enough. Recognition of the cultural importance and rights of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples has moved forward very significantly over that time, not only in Australia, but around the world. The highest priority must be given to absorbing this new understanding and balance of relationships into the culture of Parks Australia, both on the parks and in Canberra, so that it permeates not only its thinking but its action on the ground. Parks Australia needs to truly understand traditional ownership and culture and that the Commonwealth is not the owner of the land.

Despite the well-intentioned work of many Parks Australia staff on the ground, there is too little understanding of the value that can only be provided by Traditional Owners of the land. Only Traditional Owners can explain traditional lore and culture to visitors to the parks. Only Traditional Owners can understand the importance of sacred sites and the rituals and land areas set aside for women’s and men’s business. Only Traditional Owners possess the understanding of caring for Country including fire and pest control. And central to this is the importance of providing support to help Elders pass on traditional lore and practice to the younger generations before it is lost.

This practical cultural knowledge and value that only Traditional Owners can provide leads to a higher aspiration. Traditional Owners have a close identification with their Country together with a deep sense of responsibility for its management. Symbolic recognition of cultural traditions and knowledge, as well as the provision of jobs and infrastructure funding, is highly important but not enough. Traditional Owners want to use their ecological and land management skills to become more self-sustaining, to be part of business opportunities over and above assistance from government. Recognition of the very real worth of culture in a practical sense must be at the heart of the relationship and woven into the fabric of all business on the parks.

The upcoming generations on park are its future. The next generation should have the capacity, desire and expectation of playing a significant role in managing and getting jobs on Country. They should be provided the training to help them to do so, including the job-ready skills Traditional Owners may need in computing, business, or English language. Traditional Owners must have pride and enthusiasm for showcasing the parks and Australia’s unique cultural heritage.

The reverse is the case. Traditional Owners are concerned that younger generations don’t see opportunities for work on Country and that valuable traditional lore and practice will be lost. Lack of appreciation of the importance of local traditional knowledge, ineffective training, and thoughtless job design and recruitment practices have meant Traditional Owners are too often excluded. It is a sad irony that Traditional Owners may end up training a non-Indigenous person in the local traditional knowledge that is absolutely integral to the job.

Special mention must be made of non-Indigenous workers who go out of their way to mentor and assist young Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers. But it is extremely hard to motivate people in an environment where they feel set to fail. Not being able to see possible pathways from school to a future on the park is extraordinarily demoralising and there has not been a concerted practical effort to put such pathways into place.

It’s not just the younger generation that are disillusioned. Traditional Owners have become frustrated that  commitments have been made but not delivered, that the business model hasn’t changed despite the many promises that have been made, that plans on paper haven’t been converted into practical realities and that the nature of their roles as the legal owners of the land has so often been overlooked, causing a snowball effect.

As a result, there is an almost complete lack of trust in Parks Australia and thus in the Commonwealth. Traditional Owners of each park feel that Parks Australia comes first and they come, not so much second, as last. They certainly do not feel equal partners. On land that is legally their own and where their traditional culture and knowledge is fundamental, this is an untenable situation. Over time the relationship has deteriorated to a deplorable state. The slow creep of bureaucratic fog has taken its toll.

The problem cannot be laid at the feet of the occasional bad choice of personnel. There has been a systemic failure in Canberra to truly appreciate both the reality of Traditional Owners’ legal ownership and the intrinsic value of local traditional knowledge and culture. It appears as though many see Traditional Owners’ legal ownership of the land as a mere book entry rather than a legal right. In its day-to-day park operations, Parks Australia has behaved not as a lessee but as the de facto titleholder.

In its management of the parks, Parks Australia has been woefully Canberra centric. While there is an understandable requirement for a bureaucratic employment framework, Parks Australia has tried to make the parks fit the overlay without using the flexibilities allowed to make the overlay fit for purpose. Bureaucracy has spiralled out of control to kill common sense. Shifting Canberra based jobs to the parks would assist the bureaucracy to understand the day-today practicalities of life on the parks and to prioritise efforts towards park improvement. The Public Service often operates in silos and this does not make for a complete understanding of what response is required of Government.

To compound the problem there has been a failure by the Commonwealth over the decades to live up to the funding promises made. This has impacted on all aspects of park operations, including infrastructure, roads and land management, which have deteriorated rather than being enhanced. Understandably central agencies are even more removed from the parks than Parks Australia but they cannot be completely exonerated. They too must understand the implications of the advice given to government.

It is inevitable that many Traditional Owners have gradually lost trust.

The attached advice recommends changes in relation to employment, park management, infrastructure and more. These are practical things that can be done to help rebuild trust. But the benefits will only flow if cultural understanding and the relationship between Traditional Owners and Parks Australia is fixed. Cultural change within Parks Australia is the first priority. Traditional Owners care deeply about the parks and are willing and keen to work together, on the basis of an equal partnership, to protect and enhance these cultural and environmental icons. It’s that kind of resilience and determination that explains why Aboriginal people have the oldest surviving culture on the planet.

But commitments have been made before and not delivered. It’s important to note the precarious state of the relationship and warn that immediate remedial action, strategies and supporting funding particularly around infrastructure is addressed in the next budgetary cycle. If something is not done immediately it may become irreparable.

It is essential that action is taken now to deliver a new beginning.

Thanks for your feedback.
Thanks! Your feedback has been submitted.

We aren't able to respond to your individual comments or questions.
To contact us directly phone us or submit an online inquiry

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Please verify that you are not a robot.

Skip

Footer

  • Contact us
  • Accessibility
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • FOI
Last updated: 09 March 2022

© Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water

We acknowledge the Traditional Owners of country throughout Australia and recognise their continuing connection to land, waters and culture. We pay our respects to their Elders past, present and emerging.